M/I Homes (MHO) Intrinsic Value Calculator

Updated: Nov 21, 2026

M/I Homes (MHO) trades at $122.73 against a base-case intrinsic value of $80.04 — roughly a 53% premium to fair value. The model starts from $11.22 in expected earnings per share, grows it at 5.1% annually (analyst consensus) decaying to a 4% terminal rate by Year 5, applies a 9.2x exit multiple, and discounts the result back at 10% per year. At today's price, the market is pricing in either faster earnings growth or a higher exit multiple than MHO's own history supports. Use the sliders below to see what growth assumptions would be needed to justify the current price.

Overvalued by 34.8%
Current Price
$122.73
Intrinsic Value
$80.04
Implied Upside: -34.8%

Discounted Cash Flow with Growth Decay Model

Customize Your Valuation

Adjust the assumptions below to model different scenarios. The intrinsic value updates in real-time.

Conservative
Base Case
Aggressive
Time Horizon 5 years
3 years 10 years
Initial Growth Rate 5.1%
0% (No Growth) 50% (High Growth)
Terminal Growth Rate 4.0%
0% (Decline) 6% (GDP+)
Discount Rate (Required Return) 10.0%
5% (Low Risk) 15% (High Risk)
Exit PE Multiple 9.2x
8x (Value) 40x (Growth)
Calculated Intrinsic Value
$80.04
--
Tradestie Long-Horizon Cycle Intelligence (2009–2025 • Split-Invariant)

Tradestie Long-Horizon Financial Resilience & Peer Growth Benchmark (17-Year Cycle Analysis)

Outside-View Peer Growth Benchmark Operative Builders • 2498+ US Equities Benchmarked

Across 19 years of multi-cycle financial history in Operative Builders, only 81.4% of peer companies at >$1B revenue scale (102 historical 5-year windows; industry median CAGR: 11.0%/yr) sustained ≥5%/yr 5-year compound revenue growth (broad >$1B equity base rate: 50.1%).

≥5%/yr (5Y)
81.4%
All >$1B: 50.1%
≥10%/yr (5Y)
53.9%
All >$1B: 24.5%
≥15%/yr (5Y)
29.4%
All >$1B: 12.2%
≥20%/yr (5Y)
11.8%
All >$1B: 6.8%
≥25%/yr (5Y)
5.9%
All >$1B: 4.2%
≥30%/yr (5Y)
0.0%
All >$1B: 2.4%
17-Yr Revenue Scale
$570M → $4.42B
16Y CAGR: +13.7%/yr • 5Y: +7.7%
2008–2009 Cycle Trough Floor
Post-2009 Series
Tracked from FY2009
2022 Rate-Shock Floor
14.6% Op Margin
FY2023 Rev: $4.03B (-2.4% YoY)
Latest vs Cycle Median Margin
11.5% vs 7.5% med
Cyclical Margin Profile — Stress-Test Exit Multiples
Multi-Cycle Revenue & Operating Margin Trajectory (2009–2025) Expansion 2008–09 / 2022 Macro Stress
'09
-2%
'10
-3%
'11
4%
'12
6%
'13
7%
'14
8%
'15
6%
'16
7%
'17
7%
'18
8%
'19
11%
'20
14%
'21
15%
'22
15%
'23
16%
'24
12%
'25
Inspect All 17 Fiscal Years of Annual Revenue & Operating Margin History Toggle Annual Ledger ↓
Fiscal Year Annual Revenue YoY Growth Operating Income Operating Margin Macro Cycle Regime
FY2025 (2025-12) $4.42B -1.9% $507M 11.5% Standard
FY2024 (2024-12) $4.50B +11.7% $706M 15.7% Standard
FY2023 (2023-12) $4.03B -2.4% $587M 14.6% 2022–23 Shock Floor
FY2022 (2022-12) $4.13B +10.3% $637M 15.4% 2022 Rate Shock
FY2021 (2021-12) $3.75B +23.0% $518M 13.8% Standard
FY2020 (2020-12) $3.05B +21.8% $319M 10.5% Standard
FY2019 (2019-12) $2.50B +9.4% $187M 7.5% Standard
FY2018 (2018-12) $2.29B +16.5% $163M 7.1% Standard
FY2017 (2017-12) $1.96B +16.0% $139M 7.1% Standard
FY2016 (2016-12) $1.69B +19.2% $109M 6.4% Standard
FY2015 (2015-12) $1.42B +16.7% $112M 7.9% Standard
FY2014 (2014-12) $1.22B +17.2% $83M 6.8% Standard
FY2013 (2013-12) $1.04B +36.1% $59M 5.7% Standard
FY2012 (2012-12) $762M +34.5% $29M 3.8% Standard
FY2011 (2011-12) $566M -8.1% -$19M -3.3% Standard
FY2010 (2010-12) $616M +8.1% -$10M -1.6% Standard
FY2009 (2009-12) $570M — N/A — 2008–09 Cycle Stress

Year-by-Year Projections

EPS growth decays from initial rate to terminal rate over the projection period.

Year Growth Rate EPS Stock Price Present Value

Price Projection

Sensitivity Analysis

How intrinsic value changes with different growth and discount rate assumptions.

Model Inputs
Base EPS $11.22
Current Price $122.73
Historical PE 9.2x
Analyst Growth Est. 5.1%
How It Works

Growth Decay Model: We project EPS growth that gradually slows from the initial rate to a terminal rate (typically 3-4%, matching long-term GDP growth).

Terminal Value: At the end of the projection period, we apply an exit PE multiple to estimate the future stock price.

Discounting: Future values are discounted back to today using your required rate of return (discount rate).