Tradestie Institutional Equity Comparison Engine

AFG vs SIGI โ€” Head-to-Head Terminal

6-dimension institutional benchmarking across valuation, multi-year operating margins, normalized momentum, and dealer gamma corridors.

Market Close: 2026-11-16 Buy Verdict Report Ask Alpha

Pillar 1 Executive Scorecard & Category Winner Tally

AFG Overall Edge

AFG Captures Institutional Edge (2โ€“2 Pillars ยท 7โ€“3 Matrix Metrics)

Tradestie Institutional Equity Comparison Engine assigns the overall head-to-head edge to American Financial Group, Inc. (AFG) driven by superior Growth & Margin, Options & Structure while SIGI counters with relative strength in Valuation, Momentum & Technical. Fundamentally, AFG trades at 13.1x Forward P/E with 17.0% operating margin (+10.9% YoY revenue) versus SIGI at 11.6x Forward P/E and 12.8% operating margin (-2.5% YoY). In options structure, AFG sits in UNCLASSIFIED (<1st %ile IV; Dealer Gamma Walls on Pro) against SIGI sits in UNCLASSIFIED (9th %ile IV; Dealer Gamma Walls on Pro).

Valuation Winner SIGI
AFG 13.1x vs SIGI 11.6x Fwd P/E
Growth & Margin Winner AFG
Op Margin 17.0% vs 12.8% ยท YoY +10.9% vs -2.5%
Momentum & Technical Winner SIGI
1Y +11.4% vs +30.6% ยท 52W Pos 90% vs 94%
Options & Structure Winner AFG
UNCLASSIFIED (<1st %ile IV) vs UNCLASSIFIED (9th %ile IV)
AFG NYSE
American Financial Group, Inc.
Fire, Marine & Casualty Insurance
$159.45
-0.98% 1D
Market Cap $13.3B
1M Return +6.92%
1Y Return +11.36%
Forward P/E 13.1x
Unified AI Score
40.4 / 100 SELL
Tech 20.0 Fund 38.0 Flow 50.0 Mom 50.0
SIGI NASDAQ
Selective Insurance Group
Fire, Marine & Casualty Insurance
$103.78
+1.08% 1D
Market Cap $6.1B
1M Return +16.4%
1Y Return +30.61%
Forward P/E 11.6x
Unified AI Score
29.2 / 100 SELL
Tech 20.0 Fund 31.0 Flow 50.0 Mom 21.1

Pillar 2 Normalized Relative Return Performance (% Indexed to 0%)

1Y Indexed Return: AFG +11.36% SIGI +30.61% Spread: +19.25 pp (SIGI Lead)

Pillar 3 Operating Profitability Benchmark (Trailing 12-Month)

Split-Invariant Revenue ($B) & Operating Margin (%)
AFG TTM Op. Margin: 17.0% SIGI TTM Op. Margin: 12.8%
Standardized multi-year USD domestic revenue schedules are unavailable for foreign-domiciled ADR filing schedules on AFG vs SIGI. Trailing 12-month operating profitability (AFG 17.0% vs SIGI 12.8%) and valuation multiples (AFG 13.1x vs SIGI 11.6x Forward P/E) are benchmarked directly in Pillar 4 below.

Pillar 4 Head-to-Head Fundamental & Valuation Matrix

Matrix Tally: AFG (7) vs SIGI (3)
Institutional Metric AFG SIGI Criterion Row Winner
Market Capitalization Scale $13.3B $6.1B Larger Scale AFG
Trailing P/E Ratio Valuation 13.1x 12.3x Lower Multiple SIGI
Forward P/E Ratio Valuation 13.1x 11.6x Lower Multiple SIGI
Revenue Growth (YoY) Growth +10.9% -2.5% Higher Growth AFG
Operating Margin (TTM) Profitability 17.0% 12.8% Higher Margin AFG
Net Profit Margin Profitability 12.3% 9.4% Higher Margin AFG
Return on Equity (ROE) Capital Efficiency 21.6% 14.7% Higher ROE AFG
52-Week Range Position Momentum 90% ($123โ€“$163) 94% ($73โ€“$106) Stronger Trend SIGI
Beta / 30D Volatility Risk Regime -0.14ฮฒ ยท 19% Vol -0.08ฮฒ ยท 27% Vol Lower Realized Risk AFG
Unified Institutional Score Composite Signal 40.4 / 100 (SELL) 29.2 / 100 (SELL) Higher Composite AFG

Pillar 5 Options Structure, IV Regime & Dealer Gamma Corridor

Full AFG vs SIGI Buy Guide
AFG UNCLASSIFIED
0d in phase ยท OBV NEUTRAL
Put Wall Floor Pro Only
Call Wall Magnet Pro Only
IV Percentile <1st %ile
IV Regime Compressed (<25th %ile)
Live AFG Put/Call Gamma Walls & dealer positioning signals require Pro. Unlock 14-Day Free Trial →
SIGI UNCLASSIFIED
0d in phase ยท OBV NEUTRAL
Put Wall Floor Pro Only
Call Wall Magnet Pro Only
IV Percentile 9th %ile
IV Regime Compressed (<25th %ile)
Live SIGI Put/Call Gamma Walls & dealer positioning signals require Pro. Unlock 14-Day Free Trial →

Pillar 6 90-Day Technical & R&D Innovation Disclosures

Corporate R&D & Foundry Tracker
Neither AFG nor SIGI registered frontier semiconductor/AI engineering publications in the trailing 90-day window; head-to-head edge is anchored on operating margin trajectory, valuation multiples, and options structure above.