SIGI vs AFG โ Head-to-Head Terminal
6-dimension institutional benchmarking across valuation, multi-year operating margins, normalized momentum, and dealer gamma corridors.
Pillar 1 Executive Scorecard & Category Winner Tally
AFG Captures Institutional Edge (2โ2 Pillars ยท 7โ3 Matrix Metrics)
Tradestie Institutional Equity Comparison Engine assigns the overall head-to-head edge to American Financial Group, Inc. (AFG) driven by superior Growth & Margin, Options & Structure while SIGI counters with relative strength in Valuation, Momentum & Technical. Fundamentally, SIGI trades at 11.6x Forward P/E with 12.8% operating margin (-2.5% YoY revenue) versus AFG at 13.1x Forward P/E and 17.0% operating margin (+10.9% YoY). In options structure, SIGI sits in UNCLASSIFIED (9th %ile IV; Dealer Gamma Walls on Pro) against AFG sits in UNCLASSIFIED (<1st %ile IV; Dealer Gamma Walls on Pro).
Pillar 2 Normalized Relative Return Performance (% Indexed to 0%)
Pillar 3 Operating Profitability Benchmark (Trailing 12-Month)
Pillar 4 Head-to-Head Fundamental & Valuation Matrix
| Institutional Metric | SIGI | AFG | Criterion | Row Winner |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Market Capitalization Scale | $6.1B | $13.3B | Larger Scale | AFG |
| Trailing P/E Ratio Valuation | 12.3x | 13.1x | Lower Multiple | SIGI |
| Forward P/E Ratio Valuation | 11.6x | 13.1x | Lower Multiple | SIGI |
| Revenue Growth (YoY) Growth | -2.5% | +10.9% | Higher Growth | AFG |
| Operating Margin (TTM) Profitability | 12.8% | 17.0% | Higher Margin | AFG |
| Net Profit Margin Profitability | 9.4% | 12.3% | Higher Margin | AFG |
| Return on Equity (ROE) Capital Efficiency | 14.7% | 21.6% | Higher ROE | AFG |
| 52-Week Range Position Momentum | 94% ($73โ$106) | 90% ($123โ$163) | Stronger Trend | SIGI |
| Beta / 30D Volatility Risk Regime | -0.08ฮฒ ยท 27% Vol | -0.14ฮฒ ยท 19% Vol | Lower Realized Risk | AFG |
| Unified Institutional Score Composite Signal | 29.2 / 100 (SELL) | 40.4 / 100 (SELL) | Higher Composite | AFG |