14 days of Premium, free.
Every scanner with live hit rates + the Market Pulse risk flag that tells you when to get defensive. No card required.
Start trial →
Tradestie Institutional Equity Comparison Engine · Market Close Nov 16, 2026
AFG vs SIGI: Which Stock Is the Better Buy Now?
Deterministic 6-pillar institutional evaluation across valuation multiples, TTM & multi-year operating margins, cash generation, options IV skew, and supply-chain moat.
As of Nov 16, 2026, American Financial Group, Inc. (AFG) is the stronger overall head-to-head candidate over Selective Insurance Group (SIGI) in the Tradestie Institutional Equity Comparison Engine, winning 7–3 core matrix metrics and 3–2 across our 6-pillar institutional scorecard (led by Growth & Scale, Profitability & Quality, Balance Sheet & Cash Flow). AFG carries a Unified Composite Score of 40.4/100 (SELL) at $159.45 (13.1x Forward P/E, 17.0% operating margin), whereas SIGI carries 29.2/100 (SELL) at $103.78 (11.6x Forward P/E, 12.8% operating margin).
Defensive Composite Rating Caution: Although AFG compares more favorably head-to-head, both AFG (40.4/100 SELL) and SIGI (29.2/100 SELL) currently screen in defensive SELL territory (<42/100) on our Unified Composite model.
Standardized multi-year USD domestic revenue schedules are unavailable for foreign-domiciled ADR filing schedules on AFG vs SIGI. Trailing 12-month operating profitability (AFG 17.0% vs SIGI 12.8%) and valuation multiples (AFG 13.1x vs SIGI 11.6x Forward P/E) are benchmarked directly in Pillar 4 below.
Competes within the Insurance - Property & Casualty value chain with $6.1B market capitalization and 12.8% operating margin.
OpEx & R&D Reinvestment10.7% of Rev ($582M)
90D Engineering Disclosures0 Published
Investor FAQ AFG vs SIGI Key Questions & Quantitative Answers
As of Nov 16, 2026, American Financial Group, Inc. (AFG) is the stronger overall head-to-head candidate over Selective Insurance Group (SIGI) in the Tradestie Institutional Equity Comparison Engine, winning 7–3 core matrix metrics and 3–2 across our 6-pillar institutional scorecard (led by Growth & Scale, Profitability & Quality, Balance Sheet & Cash Flow). AFG carries a Unified Composite Score of 40.4/100 (SELL) at $159.45 (13.1x Forward P/E, 17.0% operating margin), whereas SIGI carries 29.2/100 (SELL) at $103.78 (11.6x Forward P/E, 12.8% operating margin). Defensive Composite Rating Caution: Although AFG compares more favorably head-to-head, both AFG (40.4/100 SELL) and SIGI (29.2/100 SELL) currently screen in defensive SELL territory (<42/100) on our Unified Composite model.
AFG leads the Growth & Scale pillar: AFG posts +10.9% YoY revenue growth and +31.9% YoY earnings growth on $8.30B TTM revenue (20.6% gross margin, 17.0% operating margin), compared with SIGI at -2.5% YoY revenue growth and +14.1% YoY earnings growth on $5.44B TTM revenue (23.5% gross margin, 12.8% operating margin). On trailing 12-month operating scale, AFG generates $8.30B in USD-normalized revenue versus $5.44B for SIGI. In operating R&D and SG&A reinvestment, AFG deploys 3.6% of Rev ($299M) (0 90-day corporate R&D disclosures) versus 10.7% of Rev ($582M) (0 disclosures) for SIGI.
SIGI screens cheaper on headline valuation multiples. AFG trades at 13.1x Forward P/E, 13.1x Trailing P/E, 2.30x PEG, and 1.6x EV/Revenue (18.2% EBITDA margin), whereas SIGI trades at 11.6x Forward P/E, 12.3x Trailing P/E, 0.28x PEG, and 1.1x EV/Revenue (13.5% EBITDA margin). Multiples above 150x or negative earnings denominators are marked N/M to avoid distorted accounting comparisons; weigh lower Forward P/E and PEG against AFG (21.6% ROE) versus SIGI (14.7% ROE) capital efficiency.
In options market volatility and institutional positioning, AFG carries 21.4% implied volatility (<1st %ile, Compressed (<25th %ile)), unclassified Put/Call open interest, NEUTRAL on-balance volume, and sits in an UNCLASSIFIED options structure phase (-0.14β · 19% Vol realized risk). By comparison, SIGI carries 32.6% implied volatility (9th %ile, Compressed (<25th %ile)), unclassified Put/Call open interest, NEUTRAL on-balance volume, and sits in an UNCLASSIFIED options structure phase (-0.08β · 27% Vol realized risk).
Cross-Compare 1-Click Peer Rivalries & Single-Stock Research
Powered by Tradestie Institutional Equity Comparison Engine & standardized corporate financial telemetry. Market close as of Nov 16, 2026. For educational research only; not investment advice.