Tradestie Institutional Equity Comparison Engine · Market Close Nov 16, 2026

SIGI vs AFG: Which Stock Is the Better Buy Now?

Deterministic 6-pillar institutional evaluation across valuation multiples, TTM & multi-year operating margins, cash generation, options IV skew, and supply-chain moat.

AFG Wins Head-to-Head Institutional Verdict (3–2 across 6 Pillars · 7–3 Matrix Metrics)

AFG Overall Winner 6-Pillar Tally: SIGI 2 – 3 AFG (1 Tie) Matrix Metrics: SIGI 3 – 7 AFG

As of Nov 16, 2026, American Financial Group, Inc. (AFG) is the stronger overall head-to-head candidate over Selective Insurance Group (SIGI) in the Tradestie Institutional Equity Comparison Engine, winning 7–3 core matrix metrics and 3–2 across our 6-pillar institutional scorecard (led by Growth & Scale, Profitability & Quality, Balance Sheet & Cash Flow). SIGI carries a Unified Composite Score of 29.2/100 (SELL) at $103.78 (11.6x Forward P/E, 12.8% operating margin), whereas AFG carries 40.4/100 (SELL) at $159.45 (13.1x Forward P/E, 17.0% operating margin).

  • Defensive Composite Rating Caution: Although AFG compares more favorably head-to-head, both SIGI (29.2/100 SELL) and AFG (40.4/100 SELL) currently screen in defensive SELL territory (<42/100) on our Unified Composite model.

Executive Snapshot Side-by-Side Composite Ratings & Technical Regime

Ask Alpha AI About SIGI vs AFG
SIGI NASDAQ
Selective Insurance Group
Fire, Marine & Casualty Insurance
$103.78
+1.08% 1D
Market Cap $6.1B
TTM Revenue $5.44B
Forward P/E 11.6x
Beta / 30D Vol -0.08β · 27% Vol
Unified Composite Score
29.2 / 100 SELL
Tech 20.0 Fund 31.0 Flow 50.0 Mom 21.1
Weinstein Technical Phase Markup · Hold / add on dips
Price above SMA50, rising 50-day trend (3.1% over 20 days), RSI 70
RSI-14: 69.9 · SMA20: $99.22 · SMA50: $91.80
AFG NYSE Head-to-Head Winner
American Financial Group, Inc.
Fire, Marine & Casualty Insurance
$159.45
-0.98% 1D
Market Cap $13.3B
TTM Revenue $8.30B
Forward P/E 13.1x
Beta / 30D Vol -0.14β · 19% Vol
Unified Composite Score
40.4 / 100 SELL
Tech 20.0 Fund 38.0 Flow 50.0 Mom 50.0
Weinstein Technical Phase Markup · Hold / add on dips
Price above SMA50, rising 50-day trend (3.0% over 20 days), RSI 66
RSI-14: 65.9 · SMA20: $154.84 · SMA50: $146.89

6-Pillar Scorecard Institutional Category Breakdown (SIGI 2 – 3 AFG)

Columns: Metric · SIGI · AFG
1. Valuation Multiples SIGI
Forward P/E 11.6x 13.1x
Trailing P/E 12.3x 13.1x
PEG Ratio 0.28x 2.30x
EV / Revenue 1.1x 1.6x
2. Growth & Scale AFG
Revenue Growth (YoY) -2.5% +10.9%
Earnings Growth (YoY) +14.1% +31.9%
TTM Revenue (USD) $5.44B $8.30B
Market Cap $6.1B $13.3B
3. Profitability & Quality AFG
Gross Margin 23.5% 20.6%
Operating Margin 12.8% 17.0%
Net Profit Margin 9.4% 12.3%
Return on Equity (ROE) 14.7% 21.6%
4. Balance Sheet & Cash Flow AFG
Cash Generation (TTM) $732M EBITDA $1.51B EBITDA
Cash Flow Margin 13.5% EBITDA Mgn 18.2% EBITDA Mgn
Net Cash / Leverage $55.02 Book/Sh · 14.7% ROE $57.12 Book/Sh · 21.6% ROE
Dividend Yield 1.66% 2.25%
5. Options & Positioning Tie
Options Structure Phase UNCLASSIFIED UNCLASSIFIED
Current IV / %ile 32.6% (9th %ile) 21.4% (<1st %ile)
Put/Call OI Skew N/A N/A
OBV Trend / Tech Phase NEUTRAL · Markup NEUTRAL · Markup
6. R&D & Supply-Chain Moat SIGI
OpEx & R&D Intensity 10.7% of Rev ($582M) 3.6% of Rev ($299M)
90D R&D Disclosures 0 papers 0 papers
Competitive Moat Cyclical / Execution-Driven Positioning Scale & Operating Efficiency Moat
Supply-Chain Role Insurance - Property & Casualty Operator Insurance - Property & Casualty Operator

Core Matrix Head-to-Head Valuation, Margin, Cash Flow & Risk Table

Core Matrix Wins: SIGI (3) vs AFG (7)
Institutional Metric SIGI AFG Criterion Row Edge
Market Capitalization
Scale
$6.1B $13.3B Larger Scale AFG
Trailing P/E Ratio
Valuation
12.3x 13.1x Lower Multiple SIGI
Forward P/E Ratio
Valuation
11.6x 13.1x Lower Multiple SIGI
Revenue Growth (YoY)
Growth
-2.5% +10.9% Higher Growth AFG
Operating Margin (TTM)
Profitability
12.8% 17.0% Higher Margin AFG
Net Profit Margin
Profitability
9.4% 12.3% Higher Margin AFG
Return on Equity (ROE)
Capital Efficiency
14.7% 21.6% Higher ROE AFG
52-Week Range Position
Momentum
94% ($73–$106) 90% ($123–$163) Stronger Trend SIGI
Beta / 30D Volatility
Risk Regime
-0.08β · 27% Vol -0.14β · 19% Vol Lower Realized Risk AFG
Unified Institutional Score
Composite Signal
29.2 / 100 (SELL) 40.4 / 100 (SELL) Higher Composite AFG
Trailing 12M Revenue (USD)
Operating Scale
$5.44B $8.30B FX-Normalized USD Scale
Gross Profit Margin (TTM)
Unit Pricing Power
23.5% 20.6% Higher Margin Quality
PEG Ratio & EV / Revenue
Growth-Adjusted Valuation
0.28x PEG · 1.1x EV/Rev 2.30x PEG · 1.6x EV/Rev Lower Multiple Valuation
Cash Flow & Balance Sheet
Capital Self-Funding
$732M EBITDA ($55.02 Book/Sh · 14.7% ROE) $1.51B EBITDA ($57.12 Book/Sh · 21.6% ROE) Higher Cash / Net Cash Solvency

Momentum Normalized Relative Price Performance (1M · 3M · 6M · 1Y)

1M Horizon SIGI +9.48 pp
SIGI: +16.4% · AFG: +6.92%
3M Horizon SIGI +4.15 pp
SIGI: +13.67% · AFG: +9.52%
6M Horizon AFG +0.65 pp
SIGI: +15.84% · AFG: +16.49%
1Y Horizon SIGI +19.25 pp
SIGI: +30.61% · AFG: +11.36%

Financial Trajectory Operating Profitability Benchmark (Trailing 12-Month)

Split-Invariant USD Revenue & Operating Margin (%)

Standardized multi-year USD domestic revenue schedules are unavailable for foreign-domiciled ADR filing schedules on SIGI vs AFG. Trailing 12-month operating profitability (SIGI 12.8% vs AFG 17.0%) and valuation multiples (SIGI 11.6x vs AFG 13.1x Forward P/E) are benchmarked directly in Pillar 4 below.

SIGI ADR TTM Benchmark FX-Normalized USD
TTM Revenue$5.44B
Gross Margin23.5%
Op. Margin12.8%
ROE / Fwd P/E14.7% · 11.6x
AFG ADR TTM Benchmark FX-Normalized USD
TTM Revenue$8.30B
Gross Margin20.6%
Op. Margin17.0%
ROE / Fwd P/E21.6% · 13.1x

Options Positioning Implied Volatility, Put/Call Skew & Dealer Gamma Corridor

Live Options Phase Tracker
SIGI UNCLASSIFIED
0d in phase · OBV NEUTRAL
Current IV 32.6%
IV Percentile 9th %ile
Put/Call OI Skew N/A
IV Regime Compressed (<25th %ile)
Put Wall Floor Pro Only
Call Wall Magnet Pro Only
Net Delta Signal NEUTRAL
OBV Flow NEUTRAL
Exact SIGI Put/Call Gamma Wall strikes & dealer pinning corridor require Tradestie Pro. Unlock 14-Day Free Trial →
AFG UNCLASSIFIED
0d in phase · OBV NEUTRAL
Current IV 21.4%
IV Percentile <1st %ile
Put/Call OI Skew N/A
IV Regime Compressed (<25th %ile)
Put Wall Floor Pro Only
Call Wall Magnet Pro Only
Net Delta Signal NEUTRAL
OBV Flow NEUTRAL
Exact AFG Put/Call Gamma Wall strikes & dealer pinning corridor require Tradestie Pro. Unlock 14-Day Free Trial →

Moat & R&D Supply-Chain Positioning, Bottleneck Moat & R&D Velocity

Corporate R&D & Foundry Leaderboard
SIGI Moat Profile Cyclical / Execution-Driven Positioning
Insurance - Property & Casualty Operator
Competes within the Insurance - Property & Casualty value chain with $6.1B market capitalization and 12.8% operating margin.
OpEx & R&D Reinvestment 10.7% of Rev ($582M)
90D Engineering Disclosures 0 Published
AFG Moat Profile Scale & Operating Efficiency Moat
Insurance - Property & Casualty Operator
Competes within the Insurance - Property & Casualty value chain with $13.3B market capitalization and 17.0% operating margin.
OpEx & R&D Reinvestment 3.6% of Rev ($299M)
90D Engineering Disclosures 0 Published

Investor FAQ SIGI vs AFG Key Questions & Quantitative Answers

As of Nov 16, 2026, American Financial Group, Inc. (AFG) is the stronger overall head-to-head candidate over Selective Insurance Group (SIGI) in the Tradestie Institutional Equity Comparison Engine, winning 7–3 core matrix metrics and 3–2 across our 6-pillar institutional scorecard (led by Growth & Scale, Profitability & Quality, Balance Sheet & Cash Flow). SIGI carries a Unified Composite Score of 29.2/100 (SELL) at $103.78 (11.6x Forward P/E, 12.8% operating margin), whereas AFG carries 40.4/100 (SELL) at $159.45 (13.1x Forward P/E, 17.0% operating margin). Defensive Composite Rating Caution: Although AFG compares more favorably head-to-head, both SIGI (29.2/100 SELL) and AFG (40.4/100 SELL) currently screen in defensive SELL territory (<42/100) on our Unified Composite model.

AFG leads the Growth & Scale pillar: SIGI posts -2.5% YoY revenue growth and +14.1% YoY earnings growth on $5.44B TTM revenue (23.5% gross margin, 12.8% operating margin), compared with AFG at +10.9% YoY revenue growth and +31.9% YoY earnings growth on $8.30B TTM revenue (20.6% gross margin, 17.0% operating margin). On trailing 12-month operating scale, SIGI generates $5.44B in USD-normalized revenue versus $8.30B for AFG. In operating R&D and SG&A reinvestment, SIGI deploys 10.7% of Rev ($582M) (0 90-day corporate R&D disclosures) versus 3.6% of Rev ($299M) (0 disclosures) for AFG.

SIGI screens cheaper on headline valuation multiples. SIGI trades at 11.6x Forward P/E, 12.3x Trailing P/E, 0.28x PEG, and 1.1x EV/Revenue (13.5% EBITDA margin), whereas AFG trades at 13.1x Forward P/E, 13.1x Trailing P/E, 2.30x PEG, and 1.6x EV/Revenue (18.2% EBITDA margin). Multiples above 150x or negative earnings denominators are marked N/M to avoid distorted accounting comparisons; weigh lower Forward P/E and PEG against SIGI (14.7% ROE) versus AFG (21.6% ROE) capital efficiency.

In options market volatility and institutional positioning, SIGI carries 32.6% implied volatility (9th %ile, Compressed (<25th %ile)), unclassified Put/Call open interest, NEUTRAL on-balance volume, and sits in an UNCLASSIFIED options structure phase (-0.08β · 27% Vol realized risk). By comparison, AFG carries 21.4% implied volatility (<1st %ile, Compressed (<25th %ile)), unclassified Put/Call open interest, NEUTRAL on-balance volume, and sits in an UNCLASSIFIED options structure phase (-0.14β · 19% Vol realized risk).

Cross-Compare 1-Click Peer Rivalries & Single-Stock Research

Launch Custom Ticker Comparison →

Powered by Tradestie Institutional Equity Comparison Engine & standardized corporate financial telemetry. Market close as of Nov 16, 2026. For educational research only; not investment advice.