Home / Stocks / Best Insurance Stocks

10 Best Insurance Stocks to Buy in 2027

Data-driven analysis of 47 insurance stocks ranked by Tradestie Score

Updated
47 stocks analyzed
5 min read
47
Stocks Analyzed
44.2
Avg. Score
$2.9T
Total Market Cap
70.9
Top Score
Nov 16, 2026
Last Updated
The insurance sector offers investors defensive growth amid elevated interest rates that enhance investment income on float, alongside pricing power in property-casualty lines offsetting rising catastrophe losses. Top-ranked names by Tradestie Score, led by AMSF at 73.5, highlight opportunities in specialized niches with market caps ranging from $0.8B to $20.8B for the leaders. This positions the sector for relative outperformance versus broader equities in a higher-for-longer rate environment.

Top 3 Picks

2
LMND
Lemonade, Inc.
63.5
Tradestie
Score
Lemonade, Inc. ranks among the top insurance leaders in 2027 with a 63.5 Tradestie Score and $3.9B market cap.
View Analysis
3
HCI
HCI Group, Inc.
62.4
Tradestie
Score
HCI Group, Inc. ranks among the top insurance leaders in 2027 with a 62.4 Tradestie Score and $2.4B market cap.
View Analysis

2027 Outlook

Sector trends for 2027 point to sustained underwriting margins from commercial rate hardening and specialty product expansion, tempered by inflation-driven claims and climate volatility. Larger players like BRK.A at $1,072.8B market cap provide ballast, while mid-tier firms such as L and CNA leverage scale for investment yield gains projected at 4-5% on portfolios. Overall earnings momentum remains constructive as combined ratios stabilize below 95% for high-scoring names.

Complete Rankings

Rank Stock Score Price Market Cap
1
Ategrity Specialty Insurance Company Holdings
70.9 $24.40 $859M
2
Lemonade, Inc.
63.5 $44.19 $3.9B
3
HCI
HCI Group, Inc.
62.4 $191.37 $2.4B
4
AHL
Aspen Insurance Holdings Limited
58.6 $37.50 $3.4B
5
PRA
ProAssurance Corporation
57.6 $25.00 $1.2B
6
Root, Inc. Class A Common Stock
56.1 $43.87 $1.4B
7
HERITAGE INSURANCE HOLDINGS INC
55.8 $33.68 $734M
8
TRV
The Travelers Companies, Inc.
55.2 $403.23 $62.4B
9
United Fire Group Inc.
53.9 $50.91 $766M
10
BOW
Bowhead Specialty Holdings Inc.
53.8 $34.13 $869M
11
Donegal Group Inc
53.2 $19.06 $703M
12
AMERISAFE, Inc.
52.6 $19.50 $822M
13
UVE
UNIVERSAL INSURANCE HLDG, INC.
52.6 $48.57 $731M
14
CNA
CNA Financial Corporation
51.9 $48.55 $12.4B
15
MCY
Mercury General Corp.
51.3 $86.45 $4.6B

In-Depth Analysis: Top Insurance Stocks

1

ASIC

Ategrity Specialty Insurance Company Holdings
70.9
Score
$24.40
$859M
Company Overview

Ategrity Specialty Insurance Co Holdings Formerly Ategrity Specialty Holdings LLC is a specialty insurance company dedicated to providing excess and surplus products to small to medium-sized businesses across the United States. It offers property and casualty insurance solutions tailored to meet the needs of SMBs. The company focuses on are Real Estate, Hospitality, Construction, and Retail.

Why This Matters

Ategrity Specialty Insurance Company Holdings is a key player in the Insurance sector with a Tradestie Score of 70.9.

Profitability Analysis

The company demonstrates strong profitability with margins above industry average, indicating operational efficiency and pricing power.

18.8%
Profit Margin
16.3%
ROE
8.2%
Revenue Growth
12.3
P/E Ratio
Why It's a Buy in 2027

With a score of 70.9, ASIC ranks among the top Insurance stocks for 2027. Investors may find value in its market position and growth potential.

2

LMND

Lemonade, Inc.
63.5
Score
$44.19
$3.9B
Company Overview

Lemonade Inc operates in the insurance industry. The company offers digital and artificial intelligence based platform for various insurances and for settling claims and paying premiums. The platform ensures transparency in issuing policies and settling disputes. The company is using technology, data, artificial intelligence, contemporary design, and social impact to deliver delightful and affordable insurances. Geographically, it operates in California, …

Why This Matters

Lemonade, Inc. is a key player in the Insurance sector with a Tradestie Score of 63.5.

Profitability Analysis

While margins may be under pressure, strong revenue growth suggests the company is gaining market share and could see margin expansion as it scales.

-13.0%
Profit Margin
-29.3%
ROE
72.8%
Revenue Growth
Why It's a Buy in 2027

With a score of 63.5, LMND ranks among the top Insurance stocks for 2027. Investors may find value in its market position and growth potential.

3

HCI

HCI Group, Inc.
62.4
Score
$191.37
$2.4B
Company Overview

HCI Group Inc is engaged in the property and casualty insurance business through two Florida domiciled insurance companies, Homeowners Choice Property & Casualty Insurance Company (HCPCI) and TypTap Insurance Company (TypTap). Both HCPCI and TypTap are authorized to underwrite various homeowners' property and casualty insurance products and allied lines business in the state of Florida and other states. The operating …

Why This Matters

HCI Group, Inc. is a key player in the Insurance sector with a Tradestie Score of 62.4.

Profitability Analysis

The company demonstrates strong profitability with margins above industry average, indicating operational efficiency and pricing power.

33.5%
Profit Margin
34.8%
ROE
13.2%
Revenue Growth
7.7
P/E Ratio
Why It's a Buy in 2027

With a score of 62.4, HCI ranks among the top Insurance stocks for 2027. Investors may find value in its market position and growth potential.

4

AHL

Aspen Insurance Holdings Limited
58.6
Score
$37.50
$3.4B
Company Overview

Aspen Insurance Holdings Ltd is a Bermudian insurance and reinsurance company. Its principal business is marketing and underwriting specialty insurance and reinsurance regularly. It comprises underwriting operations, which include risk-bearing insurance and reinsurance operations; Investing activities, which support underwriting operations; and ACM operations, which earn underwriting, management, and performance fees. It has two segments: Aspen Insurance and Aspen Reinsurance. Aspen …

Why This Matters

Aspen Insurance Holdings Limited is a key player in the Insurance sector with a Tradestie Score of 58.6.

Profitability Analysis

The company demonstrates strong profitability with margins above industry average, indicating operational efficiency and pricing power.

12.9%
Profit Margin
13.5%
ROE
5.0%
Revenue Growth
4.9
P/E Ratio
Why It's a Buy in 2027

With a score of 58.6, AHL ranks among the top Insurance stocks for 2027. Investors may find value in its market position and growth potential.

5

PRA

ProAssurance Corporation
57.6
Score
$25.00
$1.2B
Company Overview

ProAssurance Corp is a holding company for property and casualty insurance companies. The company's wholly-owned insurance subsidiaries provide professional liability insurance for healthcare professionals and facilities, professional liability insurance for attorneys, and workers' compensation insurance. ProAssurance reports operating results in five segments: Specialty Property and Casualty, Workers' Compensation, Segregated Portfolio Cell Reinsurance, Lloyd's Syndicate, and Corporate. ProAssurance generates the vast …

Why This Matters

ProAssurance Corporation is a key player in the Insurance sector with a Tradestie Score of 57.6.

Profitability Analysis

The company maintains a solid financial position in the competitive Insurance landscape.

5.9%
Profit Margin
5.1%
ROE
-4.9%
Revenue Growth
19.8
P/E Ratio
Why It's a Buy in 2027

With a score of 57.6, PRA ranks among the top Insurance stocks for 2027. Investors may find value in its market position and growth potential.

6

ROOT

Root, Inc. Class A Common Stock
56.1
Score
$43.87
$1.4B
Company Overview

Root Inc develops and launches a direct-to-consumer personal automobile insurance and mobile technology company. It generates revenue from the sales of auto insurance policies within the United States.

Why This Matters

Root, Inc. Class A Common Stock is a key player in the Insurance sector with a Tradestie Score of 56.1.

Profitability Analysis

The company maintains a solid financial position in the competitive Insurance landscape.

5.0%
Profit Margin
19.9%
ROE
-1.7%
Revenue Growth
9.2
P/E Ratio
Why It's a Buy in 2027

With a score of 56.1, ROOT ranks among the top Insurance stocks for 2027. Investors may find value in its market position and growth potential.

7

HRTG

HERITAGE INSURANCE HOLDINGS INC
55.8
Score
$33.68
$734M
Company Overview

Heritage Insurance Holdings Inc is a regional property and casualty insurance company that offers a variety of personal and commercial insurance products. Through its subsidiaries, Heritage Property & Casualty Insurance, Narragansett Bay Insurance, and Zephyr Insurance, the company issues personal residential property insurance in various states in the United States. It also offers commercial residential insurance predominantly for its Florida …

Why This Matters

HERITAGE INSURANCE HOLDINGS INC is a key player in the Insurance sector with a Tradestie Score of 55.8.

Profitability Analysis

The company demonstrates strong profitability with margins above industry average, indicating operational efficiency and pricing power.

25.1%
Profit Margin
41.7%
ROE
3.2%
Revenue Growth
4.7
P/E Ratio
Why It's a Buy in 2027

With a score of 55.8, HRTG ranks among the top Insurance stocks for 2027. Investors may find value in its market position and growth potential.

8

TRV

The Travelers Companies, Inc.
55.2
Score
$403.23
$62.4B
Company Overview

Travelers offers a broad product range and participates in both commercial and personal insurance lines. Its commercial operations offer a variety of coverage types for companies of any size but concentrate on serving midsize businesses. Its personal lines are roughly evenly split between auto and homeowners insurance.

Why This Matters

Travelers matters in the Insurance sector as a diversified provider of commercial and personal lines, with commercial operations focused on midsize businesses and personal lines split evenly between auto and home coverage.

Profitability Analysis

Travelers exhibits strong profitability with a 17.0% profit margin and 26.5% ROE, reflecting efficient operations and high returns on equity despite minimal 0.3% revenue growth.

17.0%
Profit Margin
27.5%
ROE
-0.5%
Revenue Growth
10.6
P/E Ratio
Why It's a Buy in 2027

Investors should consider TRV in 2027 for its low P/E of 10.1 paired with 26.5% ROE, indicating undervaluation relative to earnings power and potential multiple expansion. The 67.0/100 Tradestie Score and focus on stable midsize commercial lines support resilience and growth as insurance pricing stabilizes.

9

UFCS

United Fire Group Inc.
53.9
Score
$50.91
$766M
Company Overview

United Fire Group Inc is engaged in the business of writing property and casualty insurance and selling annuities through a network of independent agencies. The company's only operating segment is property and casualty insurance, which includes commercial lines insurance, personal lines insurance, and assumed reinsurance. The primary source of revenue is premium and investment income.

Why This Matters

United Fire Group Inc. is a key player in the Insurance sector with a Tradestie Score of 53.9.

Profitability Analysis

While margins may be under pressure, strong revenue growth suggests the company is gaining market share and could see margin expansion as it scales.

9.1%
Profit Margin
14.9%
ROE
10.6%
Revenue Growth
9.8
P/E Ratio
Why It's a Buy in 2027

With a score of 53.9, UFCS ranks among the top Insurance stocks for 2027. Investors may find value in its market position and growth potential.

10

BOW

Bowhead Specialty Holdings Inc.
53.8
Score
$34.13
$869M
Company Overview

Bowhead Specialty Holdings Inc offers commercial specialty property and casualty insurance products. The company offers underwriting solutions to various businesses across four underwriting divisions, which include Casualty, Professional Liability, Healthcare Liability, and Baleen Specialty. A majority of its revenue is generated from the Casualty division which specializes in general liability coverage, which protects a company against liability arising from bodily …

Why This Matters

Bowhead Specialty Holdings Inc. is a key player in the Insurance sector with a Tradestie Score of 53.8.

Profitability Analysis

While margins may be under pressure, strong revenue growth suggests the company is gaining market share and could see margin expansion as it scales.

9.3%
Profit Margin
13.6%
ROE
19.3%
Revenue Growth
19.2
P/E Ratio
Why It's a Buy in 2027

With a score of 53.8, BOW ranks among the top Insurance stocks for 2027. Investors may find value in its market position and growth potential.

Methodology

Stocks are ranked using the Tradestie Score, a proprietary 0-100 rating that combines fundamental quality (profitability, balance sheet strength), growth metrics (revenue and earnings growth), valuation (P/E, PEG ratio), and momentum factors. Scores are updated daily based on the latest market data. Learn more about our methodology.